Breast

Multiple supplements and functional foods have strong direct or indirect evidence of improving breast cancer treatment results. Overall the mechanisms frequently revolve around increased anti-tumor immune response, reduced treatment resistance and inflammation as well as balancing levels of crucial minerals and vitamins.

Studies of national patient records in Scandinavia have reported positively on the use of antihistamines. Desloratadine, loratadine and ebastine are highlighted in these studies as improving breast cancer outcomes, partly by reducing histamine related resistance to treatment. Overall evidence favoring interventions with antihistamines continues to mount, not least for supporting immunotherapy.

Similarly low dose aspirin and vitamin D3 also have growing evidence from case records of reducing progression and recurrence risks. At least one report confirming vitamin D3 improves relative survival rates 20 to 50% even for post-diagnosis use. Cancer activity, associated inflammation and drugs all deplete key nutrients such as D3.

These types of studies on the Tiawan national patient database for advanced breast cancer show much improved outcomes with use of danshen. A well researched and readily available herbal supplement, widely used in in asia to protect and re-balance immune system activity. Equally well proven astragalus can also restore immune system health, according to recent data using the well known neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio. This measure of immune related inflammation occurs commonly with cancer and during treatment, studies report lowering NLR reduces progression risks significantly.

Also reported in large scale studies of patient data for breast cancer, coffee consumption has surprising ability to reduce progression risk, in this data for ER+ tamoxifen treated patients in particular. The study shows caffeine inhibiting both estrogen and insulin growth factor receptors. Green coffee extract is also interesting since it contains far higher amounts of the active ingredients beyond caffeine. And another example from case records, prescription statin users that are “responders” for blood cholesterol control gain significant risk reduction in breast cancer.

Also from dietary sources soy consumption e.g as tofu has been linked to lowered recurrence and progression especially in postmenopausal patient groups. In other studies, progression risks are reduced with statins in the 20% range or higher. Even beyond 50%  by the simultaneous use of low dose aspirin and anti-diabetics such as metformin. Being a “responder” applies to many compounds here, aspirin for instance has stronger effects in patients with systemic inflammatory diseases.

Less well known are emerging trials of functional foods based on oats and eggs that increase anti-inflammatory responses able to counter fluid pressure in tumors. In most solid tumors this physical barrier drives not only growth and metastatic spread, but also drug resistance. Selenium is proposed has having similar activity at high enough levels- see below. Breast cancer often increases its iron availability to fuel growth, shown by levels of enzyme like protein called ferritin. Low levels are linked with improved prognosis, whilst increasing levels are seen with metastasis, particularly to the liver. Conversely, iron deficiency is common and increases during therapy, linked with much higher progression risks. The prebiotic milk protein lactoferrin binds iron in the gut and regulates iron balance, homeostasis, and has its own evidence for anti-cancer activity. The same study highlights the benefits of lowering systemic inflammation c-reactive protein (CRP), indicating the importance of anti-inflammatory supplements and functional food diets.

The so called Th1/Th2 immune system balance is strongly linked to the progression and to treatment resistance. Molecular iodine solutions are emerging in this area in breast cancer management and seen boosting Th1 anti tumor activity and helping suppress over active Th2 used in resistance. The has improved results in surgery plus chemotherapy and may support increased response immunotherapy (see Supplement Library). For immunotherapy the presence of high sodium levels is now idenfied as a key marker for success in other cancers.

High levels of heavy metals like copper, especially with insufficient selenium and zinc, are linked with poor prognosis. The exact mechanism is still being clarified, but one possibility is cancer switches the metabolism to free up copper for its needs to grow and spread rapidly, and down regulates selenium. Heavy metal detoxification has been shown in patient case studies with use of citrus pectin, ideally with marine alginates from kelp. In kidney cancer, high dose selenium has been shown to allow oncology drugs to penetrate tumors much more effectively, and has ongoing clinical studies. Another mineral, iodine  in its readily available solution form, has evidence of significantly improving outcomes. Both substantially lower risk levels for progression following surgery and chemotherapy and for reducing side effects especially for stage III.

Melatonin is being actively trialed to explore its quality of life benefits, and is reported at moderate to higher doses to slow progression for some patients. Melatonin might be a factor in the 40% or so increased response rates to immunotherapy, studied in other cancers, given in the morning vs afternoon, something to be aware of. Also new research, plant flavonoid luteolin has striking results in reducing androgen receptor activity in prostate cancer management, something also common in breast cancer. (see Supplements Library)

Lifestyle changes can impact recurrence and risk levels quite substantially. Both anti-inflammatory diets and structured exercise are increasingly reported to improve outcomes (see Lifestyle)

In repurposed drug trials, the combination of etodolac and propranolol is showing promise (see Repurposed Drugs)

Subscribe to the site for Pathfinder ANALYSIS and helpful GUIDE. Build you personal plan with confidence.

Click the IMAGE to view the library entry

Danshen evidence from patient records is compelling both in cancer and vascular health

  • Added to standard oncology treatments, patient records show long term progression risks are halved
  • Improves outcomes are comparable to those from adding a second oncology drug, but with lowered side effects
  • Taken during treatment at 3g daily from diagnosis and for at least 90 days for most benefit

The patients were also categorized into two groups according to the duration of danshen use after their breast cancer diagnosis: those who had used danshen for >28 days and those who had used danshen for ≤28 days….the use of danshen for >28 days remained highly associated with decreased mortality (the adjusted HR [hazard ratio] of danshen users for >28 days was 0.55 [vs “low” users<28 days]) …Thus, these data demonstrate the protective effects of a higher dose or longer use of danshen for patients with breast cancer….These data suggested that dans...

Antihistamines have extensive analysis of case data supporting their use

  • National scale case analysis for anti-histamine use in breast cancer patients over multiple years
  • Across a thousand patients desloratadine is reported with a 33% reduced risk
  • In the published data, ebastine also showed strong benefit in postmenopausal patients

We found a consistently improved survival of desloratadine users (HR = 0.67) [Hazard Ratio], as well as of loratadine users (HR = 0.80), relative to nonusers, regardless of patient age, menopause, estrogen receptor status or stage of the tumor, or whether breast cancer-specific or overall survival was analyzed. The survival of users of other antihistamines varied relative to non-users…Based on their safety and current use within the patient population, together with our observations, we suggest the initiation of trials of desloratadine and loratadine as treatment of breast cancer

Coffee show surprising risk reducing effects from dietary survey data

  • Around half the recurrence risk is shown for early stage ER+ patients consuming coffee
  • Particularly for ER+ type, treated with tamoxifen, also linked with less advanced tumors at diagnosis
  • Parallel lab work here shows suppression of major cancer growth pathways by caffeine

Moderate (2–4 cups/day) to high (≥5 cups/day) coffee intake was associated with smaller invasive primary tumors and lower proportion of ER+ tumors , compared with patients with low consumption (≤1 cup/day). Moderate to high consumption was associated with lower risk for breast cancer events in tamoxifen-treated patients with ER+ tumors (adjusted HR, 0.51; 95% confidence interval, 0.26–0.97). Caffeine and caffeic acid suppressed the growth of ER+ and ER−  cells. Caffeine significantly reduced ER and cyclin D1 abundance in ER+ cells.

Aspirin has a majority of analysis in its favor including all-cause mortality

  • Low frequency low dose aspirin reduced early stage recurrence around 60%, for both ER+ and ER-
  • Relative overall mortality risk similarly lowered over 40% for low frequency use due to lower progression
  • Most studies look at low dose regimes often around 75mg daily “baby aspirin” and every day use

We found that aspirin use after a breast cancer diagnosis was associated with a decreased risk of distant recurrence, breast cancer death, and death from any cause. This is all the more notable because the NHS did not find an association between aspirin use and breast cancer incidence. We speculate that the association was stronger with breast cancer death than with recurrence because recurrence is more likely to be misclassified than death. We found a modest association with duration of aspirin use. Aspirin may influence proximal rather than distal events in the cancer pathway….Abund...

Vitamin D3 and its immune system health benefits are key, higher doses being trialed

  • Large scale meta-analysis reports 6 to 14% increased relative survival with higher D3 levels
  • Crucially, higher benefits were seen for higher circulating levels so a “dose dependent” effect
  • Up to 40% relative risk reductions are seen for the highest band in patient data (see Analysis)

At or above a 23.3 nmol/L threshold, for a 10 nmol/L, 20 nmol/L, or 25 nmol/L increment in circulating 25-OH-D levels, the risk of breast cancer overall mortality decreased by 6%, 12%, and 14%, respectively. There was no significant nonlinearity in the relationship between overall survival and circulating 25-OH-D levels. Our findings suggest that there is a highly significant linear dose-response relationship between circulating 25-OH-D levels and overall survival in patients with breast cancer….adding vitamin D supplements to traditional breast cancer therapy would be expected to be ...

Red Yeast Rice or where possible a prescription statin have multiple beneficial actions

  • Halved relative risk level in “responders” who saw lowered cholesterol
  • Largest effects in ER+ tumor types, but also PR- and HER2+
  • All cause mortality 20% lower for post-diagnosis users

..the inverse association between statin use and BC mortality was partly mediated by underlying cholesterol level. The risk decrease by statin use was clear only when the serum cholesterol level decreased simultaneously..The risk reduction was robust in participants whose cholesterol level decreased after starting statins (HR, 0.49) but was non-significant if cholesterol level did not subsequently decrease (HR, 0.69). Reduced BC mortality among statin users was also observed in females with estrogen receptor–positive tumors (HR, 0.82). Overall mortality was lower among statin users vs non...

Iodine and here the I2 solution form are in development for breast cancer

  • New research shows significant benefits of molecular I2 form
  • Post treatment recurrence risk reduction of 78% by adding I2 
  • Significant side effects are also reduced in the supplement group

After surgery, all patients received FEC/TE + I2 for 170 days. I2 supplementation showed a significant attenuation of the side effects and an absence of tumor chemoresistance. The control, I2, FEC/TE, and FEC/TE + I2 groups exhibited response rates of 0, 33%, 73%, and 100%, respectively, and a pathologic complete response of 18%, and 36% in the last two groups. Five-year disease-free survival rate was significantly higher in patients treated with the I2 supplement before and after surgery compared to those receiving the supplement o...

SOY ISOFLAVONE studies are in dietary tofu and soy milk finding overall benefits

  • Post treatment recurrence reduced 18 to 28% from dietary soy at 60mg daily
  • Similar effects for all cause mortality rates, particularly stage III/ IV
  • Stronger benefits in postmenopausal women, as high as 43% risk reduction

Soy isoflavone intake was associated with significantly reduced risk of breast cancer recurrence for the overall population, with moderate heterogeneity [certainty] (HR = 0.74). After stratifying by menopause and estrogen receptor status, the effect remained significant only for the postmenopausal (HR = 0.72) and estrogen receptor–positive (HR = 0.82)…Soy products were associated with a 52% risk reduction in recurrence , and combined protein and products were associated with a 25% risk reduction in breast cancer–specific mortality for estrogen receptor...

Melatonin trials have shown longer survival rates, even in late stages, and improved side effects

  • Moderate to high melatonin reported to extend late stage survival
  • Small numbers of breast cancer patients included in data
  • Effects are dose dependent, here 1g doses are trialed in late stages

..preliminary study with a very high dose of MLT, consisting of 1000 mg/once day in the evening, was carried out in untreatable cancer patients, who failed to respond to the conventional anticancer therapies, and for whom the only available treatment was the palliative therapy. The treatment was well tolerated, and a disease control was achieved in 54% patients. These preliminary results would justify further clinical studies to generate a new interpretation of cancer control, consisting of the pharmacological reproduction of the same mechanisms responsible for the natural resistance agains...

Astragalus actions include protecting and balancing immune responses

  • This meta-analysis is across several compounds but astragalus is prominent
  • Findings are around 1/3 improved response to chemo and twice the progression free rate
  • Astragalus reduces immune inflammatory responses with similar risk reduction

In the study, the pooled data has shown that CHM [chinese herbal medicine, 3/4 including astragalus- the most common] combined with chemotherapy significantly improved the tumor response and performance status of breast cancer patients. Also, we found that the combined therapy significantly decreases adverse events caused by chemotherapeutic interventions as compared with chemotherapy alone, including nausea and vomiting at toxicity grade of III-IV, WBC reduction at toxicity grade of III-IV, and platelet reduction at toxicity grade of I–IV or III-IV

Selenium is developing kidney and ovarian cancer, high doses pulsed with oncology drugs

  • This study reports around 40% reduced risk for patients with relatively higher selenium
  • In other cancers, early interventional trials with supplements show some benefit
  • Zinc/Selenium ratio is also implicated in cancer patient prognosis

Women with lower levels of serum selenium (Se) may have a worse survival in breast cancer than women with higher levels, despite no difference in incidence of the disease…Lower overall mortality was found among women in the highest [pre-diagnostic levels] Se quartile compared to the lowest using an adjusted Cox proportional hazards model, hazard ratio 0.63. Similar results were seen for breast cancer-specific mortality, 0.60. The results of our study support that Se is associated with a lower mortality in breast cancer, not related to established prognostic factors.

Oat and egg based functional foods are entering early stage clinical trials for BC

  • Metastatic spread is strongly linked to fluid pressure in the tumor microevironment
  • Early phase breast cancer has an ongoing phase III trial with functional foods
  • Significant reductions in many side effects of oncology drugs

Many studies have demonstrated the associations between peritumoral LVD [lymphatic vessel density] and tumor grade, tumor stage, lymphatic invasion, LNM [lymph node metastasis}, and overall survival in breast cancer. Our study not only demonstrates a positive association between intratumoral LVD and LNM in breast cancer but also reveals that peritumoral LVD has a moderately stronger correlation with LNM than that of intratumoral LVD. These results suggest that peritumoral lymphatic vessels have a more important effect on metastatic dissemination in breast cancer

Lactoferrin increases iron balance and reduces anemia rates, countering cancers use of iron

  • Ferritin (marker for iron level) reported to increase relative survival 3.4X
  • Nearly 6X increased relative survival rates in low ferritin+low inflammation group
  • Improved response to immunotherapy with lower pre-treatment ferritin

[HER2+] Patients with low serum ferritin or low CRP had a median survival approximately six times longer than patients with high serum ferritin or CRP. More importantly, patients with high levels of serum ferritin or CRP had a shorter progression-free survival indicating that that trastuzumab-containing therapy was not effective . Therefore, our data suggests that cancer-associated inflammation, as assessed by serum ferritin and CRP, is either 1) inducing resistance to cancer therapies …either directly through activation of molecular pathways or indirectly through affecting the struct...

Citrus Pectin removes heavy metals such as copper and has its own anti-cancer mechanisms

  • Low copper/ high zinc have more than 2X relative cancer survival over 10 years
  • All cause mortality for lowest copper/zinc v highest is 2.26X lower
  • Both zinc and selenium deficency are linked with the poor prognosis

We have previously published survival data on this group of breast cancer patients according to serum selenium level, and now we present data on the relationship between survival and zinc, copper and cooper/zinc ratio levels. In the present study, we observed that a low serum zinc level (≤762.7 μg/L) and high copper/zinc ratio (≥1.563) was associated with a decreased overall 10-year survival and breast cancer-specific survival. We observed a clear correlation between high copper/zinc ratio levels and overall survival

Propolis has yet to fulfill a wider role in cancer but helpful here with radiotherapy

  • A small trial adding propolis to radiotherapy shows significant protective actions
  • Tendencies to increased disease free survival can be seen in the data
  • Few trials with propolis, radiotherapy seems a likely use in other cancers

The supplementation of propolis 10 days pre, during and 10 days after completing radiation therapy caused a significant down-regulation of RRM2 level [marker of DNA repair levels]..after 30 months only 16% of these patients became metastatic with longer median DFS [disease free survival] in comparison to patients received radiotherapy only …. Propolis is an effective iron chelator and disturbs the di-ferric iron center that stabilizes the tyrosyl free radical, critical for catalytic function of RRM2 small subunits

Akkermansia is increasingly reported as improving immunotherapy results

  • Progression to bone metastasis is linked to low diversity and microbiome health
  • Lack of akkermansia and other strains linked with disease progression
  • Supplements are an option short term, functional foods the sustained strategy

The lack of Megamonas and Akkermansia in the BM [patients with bone metastasis] compared with those in the NC [controls] and BN [non metastatic patients] groups was considered related to bone metastasis. Additionally, based on the distinct gut microbiota profiles, we predicted that lipid transportation and metabolism, as well as folate biosynthesis, participate in breast cancer occurrence and that steroid hormone biosynthesis influences bone metastasis. Our study demonstrated that variations in gut microbiota are associated with breast cancer occurrence and bone metastasis,...

Curcumin has evidence for reducing levels of systemic inflammation used by cancers

  • Lower inflammation levels indicated 30 to 65% reduced risks
  • C-reactive protein at high level >10mg/dL indicates high risk
  • Anti-inflammatory diet and curcumin have significant actions in trials

Elevated plasma CRP measured before treatment in patients with early-stage breast cancer is an independent biomarker of increased risk of recurrence and early death. CRP measures before treatment might be used to individualize follow-up of patients with early-stage breast cancer. A doubling of the plasma CRP concentration was associated with increased risk of recurrence and shorter survival. Survival was shorter in patients with plasma CRP levels of 3 to 10 and >10 mg/L versus <3 mg/L, with multivariate adjusted HR

Support us and get our essential pathfinder GUIDE. Impacts Analysis, Usage and doses, EXAMPLE plan and supporting comments

Help grow the community

Join the Pubmedders subscriber base

Get our monthly email newletter – designed so you can give us your opinions, thoughts and feedback…

ALL contributions are invested into growing the site to help others.